The Resurrectionist by A. Rae Dunlap
First line: To hear my mother tell the story, my decision to abandon my studies at Oxford was enough to disgrace my father into an early grave.
Summary: James Willoughby has left his studies and life at Oxford for the chance at the new learning happening at Edinburgh University. In his hopes of becoming a surgeon he has enrolled in one of the private anatomy schools but it comes with a high price tag. Being short on funds he seeks employment with the school but the work is not exactly what he was expecting. In order to gain the specimens for the school, a group calling themselves Resurrectionists, are in charge of stealing fresh bodies from the cemeteries of Edinburgh. While not legal, the actions are necessary to the students seeking the knowledge of the human body and learn their trade.
However, there seems to be a new crew that has started to take over the body snatching market. This new crew seems to be able to procure the freshest of specimens and will not tolerate any competition. As James and his fellow Resurrectionists try to discover how they are pulling off these snatches they learn that this crew will even murder to keep their advantage. But they must do it before they are the next targets of the nefarious Burke and Hare!
My Thoughts: Until a few years ago I had never heard of Burke and Hare. These notorious “body snatchers” from the dark streets of Edinburgh were a big deal during their time. When I saw this book come across my desk I knew I had to read it.
I did really enjoy the story and the characters but I struggled with how loosely based on the facts the author was. So if you are someone familiar with the history then I recommend going in to this without too much expectation of historical accuracy. But the plot was interesting and exciting!
I thought the author did a great job bringing this dark underside of medical history to life. She explains the ways that families tried to stop body snatching from happening including metal collars, mort safes, tokens in the soil and watchmen but it did little good for many. It seems rather shocking that this happened but the laws around cadavers was very strict and the medical world was desperate. It definitely gives the reader something to think about in morality as well as innovation.
The atmosphere of the book is written well. It felt cold, dark and gothic. Just like the city itself. Having visited Edinburgh in April 2022, I was familiar with several of the locations mentioned in the story. As I read I could remember the cold, rainy days we walked up the cobbled streets and through the Closes all over Edinburgh’s Old Town. However, my favorite recollection while reading was our time spent wandering around Greyfriar’s Kirkyard. It is probably the best known cemetery in Edinburgh filled with old gravestones, mort safes and inspiration for several of J.K. Rowling’s characters. This place possesses a distinctly gothic atmosphere.
FYI: If you are looking for more information on Burke and Hare, I’d highly recommend the podcast episode, Burke & Hare: Scotland’s Most Notorious Serial Killers, done by After Dark on the History Hit channel.
